RESOURCES
Published 2026-11-09 · 3 min read
M4A vs. MP3: what is an M4A file, and should you convert it?
M4A is MPEG-4 audio, usually AAC. How it differs from MP3 and MP4, what plays it, and how to convert M4A to MP3 without wasting quality.
What is an M4A file?
An M4A file is an MPEG-4 file that contains only audio. The audio inside is usually AAC, a lossy codec, and occasionally ALAC (Apple Lossless). Apple popularised the .m4a extension so that audio-only MPEG-4 files could be told apart from .mp4 videos; the container itself is the same.
- Songs bought from the iTunes Store (AAC at 256 kbps).
- Recordings from the iPhone's Voice Memos app.
- Exports from Apple's Music app, GarageBand and many recording apps.
- Related extensions: .m4b for audiobooks with chapters, .m4r for iPhone ringtones, and .m4p for older copy-protected iTunes purchases, which ordinary converters can't read.
M4A vs. MP3: the differences that matter
AAC was designed as MP3's successor, and at the same bitrate it generally sounds better, most noticeably at 128 kbps and below. At high bitrates both are good enough that compatibility usually decides.
- Compatibility: M4A plays on iPhone, Mac, Windows 10 and 11, Android and in browsers. MP3 also plays on old MP3 players, many car stereos and other hardware that predates AAC.
- Quality per megabyte: AAC in M4A is the more efficient codec.
- Lossless option: an M4A can hold ALAC; an MP3 is always lossy.
- Tags: both carry title, artist, album and cover art.
MP3 vs. MP4 vs. M4A
MP3 is a single audio codec in its own file type. MP4 is a container that usually holds video plus audio. M4A is that same MP4 container holding audio only, so an audio-only .mp4 and an .m4a are essentially the same kind of file with different names.
If what you have is a video and you want just the sound, extract the audio rather than renaming the file.
How to convert M4A to MP3
Online: upload the M4A, choose MP3, and download the result. Nothing to install, which helps when a car stereo, older player or upload form needs an MP3 right now.
In Apple's Music app on a Mac, or iTunes on Windows, set Import Settings (in the app's settings, under Files on a Mac or General in iTunes) to MP3 Encoder, select the tracks, then choose File → Convert → Create MP3 Version. The MP3 copies appear next to the originals in your library.
With ffmpeg: ffmpeg -i input.m4a -c:a libmp3lame -q:a 2 output.mp3. This is the same encoder and quality setting Convyx uses.
Does converting M4A to MP3 lose quality?
Yes, a little. AAC to MP3 is a lossy-to-lossy conversion: the MP3 encoder works from audio that has already been compressed once. With a typical 256 kbps AAC source and LAME's V2 setting (around 170–210 kbps on average), the difference is rarely audible, but each further round trip loses more. Convert once, from the original, and keep the M4A.
If you need a version that sounds exactly like the M4A, for an audio editor for example, convert to WAV instead. The WAV is much larger but adds no further loss. Convyx writes 16-bit WAV, and embedded cover art is not carried over.
Going the other way: MP3 to M4A
Converting MP3 to M4A never improves the sound: it re-encodes audio that MP3 has already compressed. Do it only when an app or device specifically asks for M4A. Convyx encodes M4A as AAC at 192 kbps.